6/15/2008

Homage to the Bechers

"...no one can claim to have truly seen something unless he has photographed it." --Emile Zola


Bernd and Hilla Becher, the German industriologist-photographer couple known for their "typologies," have had a broad influence on the contemporary practice of photography. The typologies, spanning the bulk of the duo's career, are selections of images of various classes of building, arranged into formal series. There are several ways to look at this work, which sits firmly at the intersection of documentary and art photography.


Their relentless cataloging, the obsessive focus on building type, each with its limited and specific use, be it industrial or agricultural, acts to preserve in the historic record a vernacular expression of function; there will never be a better resource for future historians researching, for instance, the shape and construction of the water tower once it has faded into obsolescence.


In the context of photography and the (perhaps flawed) historical conception of what the fundamental artistic essence of that medium is, however, the Becher's work is far more than a visual list of inspirational architectural elements, like a collection of butterfly wings. Beyond the evident care with which the Bechers chose, composed and exposed, there is, in the tireless repetition of subject, a firm commitment to the modernist project. (My photographs here, quick stop-and-snaps, were made with considerably less attention to composition and light, additional layers of coherence in the Becher oeuvre.) After looking at ten grain elevators one appreciates their common elements; spending time with twenty-five one begins to consider what makes each unique; and after fifty one ponders what it is that makes a good photograph, with the subject becoming almost peripheral. Certainly you will never look at a real-life grain elevator the same way again. Is it possible that your relationship to the photograph itself has changed as well?


In this way the Becher's work reminds me of Giorgio Morandi, who repeatedly painted the same collection of empty glass bottles, from time to time gently rearranging them on a tabletop in his studio, for decades. Looking at these paintings, content, what there was of it, slips away, evaporating entirely. In his resolutely figurative canvases, repetition begets abstraction.


But the typologies are also the narrative of a couple spending life on the road together, in that they may be read as a kind of a travel journal. The images, annotated with the date and location of their capture, trace journeys through the Ruhr valley or the American high plains. With a certain facetiousness Hollis Frampton is said to have disparaged the very notion of "non-narrative" film as practiced by his contemporary Stan Brakhage, who was focused on inventing a non-linguistic visual poetry, by remarking that every film includes within it the narrative of its own making. While edging towards a reductio ad absurdum, in the case of the Bechers, the notion, especially for fellow-travelers unwittingly following their footsteps across the great northern plains decades later, adds an interesting dimension to the work.

Here, the grain elevator is not defunct. It still rises over the prairie, often the only prominent architectural feature to be found piercing Big Sky country. But where did the Bechers stop for lunch? Not at the strip mall. It wasn't there yet, at least not on the first trips they made, of many. Did they stay at the Hi-Line motel? Perhaps they packed picnics and ate them in the shade of the grain elevators. How were two Germans received, some thirty years after the close of World War II, as they drove from one dusty feedlot to the next, spending endless hours installing their large format camera on its tripod, searching for the perfect angle, waiting for the perfect light, the perfect sky? What did they explain to the county sheriffs, and the predecessors of the Department of Homeland Security?




6/13/2008

Coincidence, or inspiration?

Given that the Suddeutsche Zeitung ran my photo of the gasoline infrastructure being swallowed up by the jungle on Monday, and that only one blog post earlier I signaled Camilo José Vergara as an important photo-chronicler of collapsing American architectures, I'm wondering just where the New York Times came up with the brilliant idea to run some of Vergara's photos of defunct gas pumps on the op-ed page today, Friday, the 13th.

"I have often been amazed by the ways harsh and aggressive forms are taken over by the natural world," Vergara writes. Amen to that, and boy do we love scooping the Times.


Also in the NYT today, our nomination for humanitarian-of-the-year award goes to one Mr. Louie Brundidge, mentioned in the final graphs of a story about flood devastation in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, where the Cedar River is as much as 17 feet over its banks and the entire city center is below the surface. A guy named Demenick Ankum "drove to his house on 19th Avenue to save anything he could. By the time he finished packing, his car was underwater. He had to pay a neighbor, Louie Brundidge, $10 to rescue him from the house in Mr. Brundidge's red aluminum boat."

How's that for your fabled midwestern hospitality? Thanks so much, Louie, you are a gentleman and a patriot, valiantly upholding the values our great nation is known for. We're sure your mother was proud to have you.

6/10/2008

I knew this whole blogging thing was going to pay off eventually...

One of the many sharp-eyed antarcticiana-reading newspaper editors around the globe thought this image from our recent travels was too good to pass up, and slapped it on the front page of Monday's edition of one of Europe's major dailies. Well, at least one section of the paper, the uniquely European "feuilleton." What's more, instead of simply stealing it, they actually contacted me and purchased it, in cold hard euros, the new dominant world currency. If anyone has enough German to offer a translation of the photo caption in the "comments," it would be much appreciated. We're getting something about the ruins of an obsolete culture, but by the time we muddle our way down to what seems to be the mention of a Croatian engineer, we've pretty much lost the thread...

6/05/2008

Transcontinental Gas Guzzle, part 5, Blighted Industry edition

The final installment of the transcontinental marathon took us down through Michigan, around Ohio's shores and across northern Pennsylvania, areas firmly situated in the rust belt, the faded industrial heartland that was the United States' steel and auto production epicenter and blue-collar paradise. Definitively outsourced, downsized and globalized into obsolescence over the last thirty and more years, this region now offers an abundance of unique fixer-upper opportunities for those willing and able handymen still able to get a home-improvement loan during this time of difficult credit.

Saginaw pawnshop awaits your TLC and weed-killer.


Bring a sheet of plate glass and some merchandise to this breezy former pharmacy in Saginaw and you will be back in business in no time!


Civic pride in Flint

Detroit has the only abandoned skyscrapers I'm aware of, classic gems standing tall and empty. See Forgotten Detroit for photographs and histories of these ghostly buildings. The photographer Camilo José Vergara has also been making images of many of these buildings for years.


This mural fantasy, of a sylvan glade butted up against the cerulean waters of Lake Erie or Lake Michigan, was probably originally painted here to bring some cheer to this dismal block of abandonment. Unfortunately the dilapidated police barricades, meant to prevent the use of the sidewalk, and the fallen and falling shattered slate cladding peeling off the building, rather diminish the effect.

6/02/2008

Transcontinental Gas Guzzle, part 4, North Woods edition, Updated

Duluth smelled of lumberyard. The entire town was pervaded with the not unpleasant but unexpectedly strong odor of a freshly opened bag of mulch. Near the waterfront we discovered, in a broad expanse of decaying industrial real estate, perhaps some sort of rail yard, an enormous mound of wood chips, sending puffs of steam up into the cold, moist air from heat generated deep in its woody bowels. There were chill winds blowing off of Lake Superior, but Duluth still seemed to have a gray, immovable ceiling, a dense, oppressive blanket of cloud and fog pressing down upon it. If this is late May in northern Minnesota, what must February be like? We thought of the music of Low, area rockers who make ponderous, dirgelike pop of the sort that suggests why Scandinavians suffer from unusually high rates of suicide.

Although we had earlier that day crossed a narrow northern tendril of river sharing the name of the mighty Mississippi, it was only after crossing the bridge into Wisconsin that we felt we had truly arrived in the east. The south shore of Lake Superior resembled nothing so much as the Maine woods, with clumps of birches running in narrow bands through the dominant conifers, and loons cackling on densely wooded ponds. Our remote, interior campground was surrounded by pristine forest, although it suffered from a certain lout factor; it was the last night of Memorial Day weekend, and more than one campsite was occupied by festive high-school youth.


After dark, they quieted down, perhaps to tell ghost stories around the campfire; we heard nothing but the steady rush of the Coleman lantern and the onomatopoetic cries of a team of Whippoorwills. Then started up a repetitive, high-pitched monosyllabic call, beaming out through the woods like a metronymic radio beacon. (Or, as we read later in the National Geographic Field Guide, "a monotonously repeated single-note whistle"). It had none of the eerie quality of an owl, hooting or screeching, but it was an undoubtedly avian sound, and we followed it, tiptoeing through the dark woods to a clump of pine trees clustered around the water-pump. Whee, whee, whee, whee, whee, the thing called, from somewhere just overhead. Weep, weep, woop, whoops, I whistled clumsily back, while peering about in the foliage, thanks to my Petzl, a tiny LED headlamp I was wearing strapped to my head, like an emasculated miner. "Be serious. You're not going to see anything with that feeble light," said Laura. But my imitation was enough to pique the bird's curiosity, and soon, like an apparition, a whitish ball of fluff flitted noiselessly through the soft beam. With it, the whistling moved closer, and lower. I persisted, whistling more softly, like, I thought, an unattended infant's version of the adult call coming down from overhead. Then it came, and sat on a branch not three feet over our heads, wide-eyed, seeking the intruder in my headlamp: a cute and cuddly (unless you are a small rodent or nestling, in which case substitute the adjectives terrifying and ominous) adult Saw-whet Owl, all of six inches tall.

"Watchu doing in my grove?"

Michigan’s Upper Peninsula felt as much like Maine as the tip of Wisconsin had; all through the long morning’s drive across it we expected at any moment to see a big bull moose striding through one of the countless moss-encircled bogs. The roadside stands selling “pasties,” venison jerky and wild rice, all apparently local specialties, had many postcards depicting moose, but we saw no real ones.


East Hampton? Cape Cod? No, it’s the raging surf of Lake Superior!

Once over the Mackinac Bridge into Michigan proper, we headed to the jack-pine flats of Oscoda County and a chance at one of the United States’ rarest birds. Certainly its rarest warbler: while the Bachman’s warbler, once a denizen of the expansive bamboo swamps of the south, still hopefully appears in most bird guides, it is “presumed extinct.” (What’s that you say? You didn’t know much of the south was once covered in bamboo forest? That’s because it has been many generations since this habitat was wiped out, the bird lingering on in a few last corners until inevitably capitulating to humankind’s excesses.) That leaves Kirtland’s warbler, some 3000 surviving individuals of which breed only in the scrubby pine forests of north-central Michigan.

After a tranquil night in the county park campgrounds of Mio, Michigan, we rose early for a 6:45 rendezvous at the Mio Ranger station. During the breeding season, when male Kirtland’s warblers are singing, the forest service escorts hordes of drooling birders to see them on their territories. These officially sponsored jaunts always involve some sort of briefing to go with the handholding, and this one was no exception. At 7AM sharp we packed into a conference room with a good dozen hardcore binocular toting obsessives to watch an orientation video on the warbler, its habitat, and the National Forest Service’s efforts to preserve both. The bulk of the crowd looked, I’m embarrassed to say, much the way I will inevitably look in ten to fifteen years: paunchy and gray-bearded, wearing ill-fitting acreages of gore-tex and frumpy hiking boots, with Germanic ground-glass binoculars running into the low four figures looped around their necks. Oops: I’m told that except for the gray in the beard I already fit this description.

Then, the chill morning air crackling with anticipation, we possed up, clambering into our out-of-state vehicles to convoy behind an avocado-green forest service SUV.

Caravan of the obsessed, following the forest service out of Mio. When I pulled into the police station the night before to ask directions to the forestry office, the cop said "just go back to the traffic light...." And I said: "that traffic light just down the block?" "Yeah, yeah," the officer replied, dismissively, "it's the only one in the county."

Kirtland’s warbler has not made life easy for itself. For reasons which remain unclear, it breeds only in young stands of jack-pine between five and twenty-five feet tall, which is to say trees about seven to twenty years old. It nests on the ground, and only chooses large stands of pine, eighty acres being the minimum requirement.

Whatever Darwinian enhancements led it to its extraordinarily finicky degree of specialization almost caused its demise in the modern age. Both the jack-pine and the bird historically require fire. In the past, new tracts of young trees resulted from lightning strikes and the resultant natural forest fires; jack-pine cones do not even pop open and release their seeds until the heat of a burn sweeps over them. But the success of the Smokey the Bear fire awareness campaign and our own species' general antipathy toward forest fires, even when they are a necessary safety valve, almost caused Kirtland's warbler's extinction; in the seventies there were as few as 175 pairs of warblers hanging on.

Young jack-pine habitat, looking much like a Christmas tree plantation

The warbler likely only exists today because of conservation dollars and intensive management. Fire is no longer used to create habitat, but the jack-pines, once they have grown too tall to please the bird, are now harvested and pulped, and the land reseeded. Prime habitat looks almost exactly like the more coniferous portions of South Jersey's scrubby Pine Barrens.

Our convoy pulled to a halt beside a large expanse of five to seven foot tall pines, along a sandy dirt road southwest of Mio.
"The warblers like sun, and it's obviously overcast, and they like to be warm, and as you can tell it is quite cold out here," said our guide, preparing us for the worst. "But I'm hearing one singing over here somewhere." She gestured behind her.
"That sounds nothing like the recording we've been listening to over and over in the car these past few days," commented one birdo.
"The song is quite variable, unlike many other warblers," said our guide. "And very loud. That one is quite far away still."

We walked down the road. Another Kirtland's called, off to our left (2868). The group turned as one, scanning the remnant, leafless oaks jutting above the level of the pines, on which the singing males often like to perch. Far, far away, I saw a tiny flash of movement in the snaggy branches. "I think I've got it," I said. "Not much of a view." It was a plump, even rotund, warbler, yellow below, the sides of the barrel chest streaked with black. Gray-blue above. Distant. It sang again, extraordinarily loudly, I thought, for a bird its size. And so far away. By now those in the party with sixty-power spotting scopes had planted their tripods and had the singing bird framed in their overpriced optics. We all had a turn looking. It was, I must admit, rather underwhelming, not much more than a small blob of partially backlit feathers, vibrating in the extremely narrow field of view of the zoom lens.

Observers, wondering if the small, blue and yellow bird, singing its heart out some eighty yards away, will ever come any closer

It was extraordinarily cold, and our convoy of birdos had charged off into the bush without so much as glancing down Mio's main street to see if there was an espresso shack. The birds, happy to sing somewhere off on the horizon, also seemed happy to stay there instead of popping in for a closer visit (we could not walk out to them for fear of trampling on a nest). These factors conspired, and while some of the group determined to stay on and stamp their feet, waiting for sun, warmth, and better looks, we said adieu. The Kirtland's warber was never, after all, going to come and perch over our heads like the Saw-whet owl had, and we were still basking in that experience.

UPDATE:
By fortuitous coincidence, within an hour of posting the above, one of our fellow party of intrepid Kirtland's spotters emailed, proving that those who stayed behind and braved the cold were finally treated to superior looks at the bird. As we were leaving I had given my card to Dan Brown in hopes that antarcticiana's readership might have a chance to actually see something resembling a warbler, since with the views I had, my 300mm lens would have captured nothing but a murky dot. Such gambits rarely work, since those one meets in the field and ask for photos seem invariably never to follow through, so I am particularly indebted to Mr. Brown.



Photos courtesy Daniel Lee Brown. Many Thanks!

5/30/2008

Just a weedy memory...

Never again, I tell you. Never again! Get out while you still can. (It's time to move on). A relic of the petroleum age, somewhere in north-central Pennsylvania.

5/29/2008

Prehistoric Marketing (Updated 02/17/2017)


We're thinking this purveyor of America's arterial fluid needs to update its logo, or else fully embrace the irony of selling gasoline under the sign of the brontosaurus. Found in abundance (these gas stations, not the brontosaurii) in a wide swath of the west, from Montana all the way to Wisconsin, these guys take the selling of fossil fuels seriously.

People in the developing world are starving because the demand for grain crops to make ethanol, and the land on which to grow them, has already doubled the cost of rural third world staples like rice, corn and wheat. Even if this fact alone were not enough to eradicate ethanol's spurious claims to "greenness" and sustainability, it turns out the demand for ethanol crops is encouraging further Amazon rainforest destruction, as more irreplaceable forest is cleared for planting. Perhaps Sinclair, without having to rebrand itself or change its cute "brontie" logo, might reposition themselves for success (however short-term) as the only company selling 100% petroleum, 100% percent of the time. "Pure Fossil Power" has a certain ring to it.



Update: While working on an entirely different project, I recently stumbled on the artwork from an old can of "Pennsylvania" Sinclair Motor Oil that explicitly markets itself as fossil fuel, playing, perhaps, on the idea that age makes a product better, like fine wine:



Image used without permission.

5/26/2008

Transcontinental Gas Guzzle, part 3: High Plains Drifter edition



East of the Marais Pass and the continental divide, Route 2 follows the railroad tracks of the Hi-Line right the way across northern Montana, from one small single-stoplight town to another. Only the grain elevators stabbing up into the sky beside the tracks mark the skyline above the expansive plains of this endless state. At Glasgow we turned south, tempted by a remote campsite mapped on the shores of Fort Peck Lake, the enormous reservoir created by the first of the dams exploiting the power of the Missouri River.

Delightful lakefront solitude. Not another camper was to be found. The new tent has now survived two nights of use without being blown away or forgotten.

Grasslands on the shores of Fort Peck Lake, at Camp 5 inside the Charles M. Russell National Wildlife Refuge

North Dakota is said to be the least visited state. This is perhaps unsurprising, as only the true plains addict would appreciate its charms. Apart from the legendary hospitality: In Fargo, butted hard up against Minnesota at the state's easternmost edge, we stopped for a night with Allan and Hazel Ashworth. Allan is the geology professor who was kind enough to share his antarctican field camp with our film crew a year and a half ago. Despite those two months in the frozen wilds submitting to the indignities of sharing an open-air toilet, not to mention being filmed daily, Allan invited us, after a last minute call, to stay the night. We had a lovely dose of plains hospitality, ate our first Thai meal since Queens, and saw our first black people since Portland, the latter two things suggesting just how far Fargo has come since Allan and Hazel first arrived here, from Surrey, England, in 1969. Culture shock is too mild a term to describe their reaction to landing in what was then a diminutive, provincial, ice-bound town, something like a transplanted outpost of northern Scandinavia, with all its racial diversity. But Fargo is slowly changing for the better. At the restaurant the adjacent table held a large extended family of Indians, as in people from India, and a sizable population of resettled refugees from the horn of Africa now call the city home.

The story of the drive across North Dakota is one of a grueling three-hundred-mile battle against a constant forty-mile-an-hour headwind. Despite stops at the Arrowwood National Wildlife Refuge and a few other select patches of preserved prairie, almost none of the ornithological specialties of this endangered habitat, once the natural state of huge areas of the plains, showed themselves. No surprise, since the few birds which lifted up off of the grasslands at our approach immediately wheeled off downwind, flapping as hard as possible to avoid being slammed back down into the matted grass by the gusts. With the bird trip list suffering from a distinct lack of prairie birds, Allan suggested a sort of last-chance stop just over the Minnesota border at a postage-stamp sized patch of Nature Conservancy land, Bluestem Prairie. He served up breakfast, scribbled a map on a sheet of notebook paper, and we said au revoir to Fargo.

Shortgrass prairie may not be everyone's idea of a must-see sort of a habitat, resembling as it does an unkempt, unmowed field. It has no majestic Redwoods, no epic stands of conifers or rafts of ducks to be glimpsed dabbling on shimmering lakes. Few people have seen pristine shortgrass prairie, not only because it is perhaps perceived as unspectacular, but because only one-tenth of one percent of the former prairie still exists. One out of one thousand acres of the vast western midwest. The other 999 are now used to grow corn, or wheat, or run cattle, or have been paved over to make Wal-mart parking lots. These various concentrated monocrops have gravely diminished the biodiversity of the region, for healthy, unaltered shortgrass prairie like the Bluestem preserve, harbors up to three hundred species of wildflower and many special birds.

Bluestem Prairie, near Glyndon, Minnesota

Violet Wood Sorrel Oxalis violacea

The delights of the prairie, varied and unexpected, but modest in scale, are to be found nestled in amongst its diverse grasses. Spring has come late this year, but purple, yellow, red and white wildflowers were blooming in clumps everywhere between the windblown stems of sedge. Mauve Pasque flowers, like tiny tulips; Marsh Marigolds, more like buttercups than marigolds, growing right out of puddles and the watery ditches; and Swamp Lousewort, a bizarre conate spiral protrusion dotted with yellow petals. A long-sought bird, the Sedge Wren, was common in the brushier patches of prairie, and another, the Upland Sandpiper, nests in its tall grasses. We found five of the latter patrolling the stubbly chaff of an adjacent field.


Not yet blooming: Prairie Smoke, Geum triflorum, aka "Old Man's Whiskers." When the plant flowers, clumps of hairy white tendrils emerge to wave in the breeze.

Heading for Duluth, the prairie and the plains imperceptibly receded in the rearview mirror, until, without quite noticing how it had happened, we found ourselves surrounded once again, for the first time since crossing the Rockies, with forest.

Plant identification consultation provided by L. F. Harmon.

5/24/2008

Transcontinental Gas Guzzle, part two

Glacier National Park rorschach.

Camp 3 at Glacier NP. One night under the stars was enough, and the missing tent has been replaced. Just in time,too, as it poured all night. Late May and the park still wasn't really properly open for the season. Remnant piles of snow (not pictured) and an endless carpet of lichen, branches and leaf litter gave a sense of how long and violent the northern Montana winter must be. There is now a fifty dollar fine levied for leaving any items of food or even items which may have "food odors" out unattended, since this place is wall to wall with grizzly bears. We didn't see any.

Calypso bulbosa, a diminutive but spectacular solitary orchid of the evergreen forest floor.

An intensely beautiful forest, rather like the Maine woods on steroids.

Camp 4. A second successive night huddled under the blue polytarp, cooking ramen over a bunsen burner was deemed rather too much adventure, so we retired in comfort to the Hi-Line motel, named, like almost everything else along Route 2, for the legendary trans-Rockies train line it follows. Here, as opposed to the rest of the country, where paved roads soon made the train tracks all but obsolete, the rail line is still a focus of town life and commerce. Enormous lengths of freight, mostly extra long containers, piled double, in snakes of hundreds of cars, chugged by at all hours. This was in Havre, Montana, where the waitress at the casino-restaurant (a designation which means that one can play Keno while eating, or stop at one of a dozen or so video one-armed bandits on the way to the toilet) told us "Havre is the biggest town on the Hi-Line, which is kind of sad, really."

5/20/2008

Transcontinental Gas Guzzle, part one

Flew out to Oregon to help Laura drive her trusty pickup back east; I've never driven all the way across the country in one go before. The trip started auspiciously, as we headed out of Portland late in the afternoon on the day of Obama's record-breaking political rally. Yesterday's newspapers showed a sea of bodies crushed together, eagerly listening to what he has to say. He is looking more and more like a lock for the nomination; it seems like only a matter of days, or even perhaps hours, before Hil throws in the towel. Already she must be alienating more voters, former supporters and superdelegates than she could possibly be attracting, and so we hope that for her own sake she moves quickly, in the painful process of decisively losing, from denial to acceptance.

Camp One, At Beacon Rock, in the Cascades, in the spectacular Columbia River valley, a spot Lewis and Clark passed as they were nearing the end of their journey. Although they could not yet see the Pacific Ocean, the sight of the seagulls patrolling the upstream reaches of the mighty river must have warmed their hearts.

Wild Bleeding Heart, a typical understory wildflower of the Cascadian Douglas Fir forest.

Round Lake rorschach, Idaho Panhandle, dawn. The eerie calls of breeding Red-necked grebes gabbling in the marshy verges of the lake accompanied our dinner of couscous and grilled asparagus. The site of Camp Two.

Camp Two. But what's missing from this photo? You noticed? How lovely, you may be be thinking, it was such a wonderful, starlit night, and the temperature so mild, that they dispensed with the claustrophobia of the tent altogether, sacking out al fresco. How mistaken you are! While unpacking the truck beside mosquito-infested Round Lake I discovered that one of us had left the bundled-up tent on the picnic table at Camp One, four hundred miles back down the road. I'm far too gallant to tell you who was responsible for this calamity, but she later claimed to have been distracted from packing by some wildflowers that needed urgent collecting. Something similar happened to me once before, in Africa, but that time, there was no one else to blame.

Camp Two, detail. Harmonian mosquito avoidance strategy. Note the crisp, brand-new blue polytarp we purchased only fifty miles back down the road at the Coeur D'Alene Walmart, "to protect the bottom of the tent."

Skunk cabbage. One hoped that the upside of setting up camp next to a pungent, stinky patch of this gigantic swamp-tobacco would be diminished mosquito activity. Sadly not.

Thank goodness it didn't rain, although that might have kept the bugs down. Apparently Mrs. Clinton still hasn't capitulated.

5/09/2008

Reading: My Colombian War by Silvana Paternostro

“…even if Colombia is a failed state that scares me to the point of blindness, that angers me to the point of blindness, that hurts me to the point of blindness, it is where I come from.”

Colombia remains for most people just another banana republic, source of cocaine and druglords. That the country has more recently become the easiest place in the world to be kidnapped is just one more of the factoids that keep the country far down at the bottom of most lists of fantasy vacation spots.

Little considered is that the kidnapping, and to a large extent the drugs, are really just footnotes to Latin America’s longest running conflict, a blurry and muddled war that has seen decades of intermittent slaughter and positively Darfurian waves of “internally displaced persons,” or IDPs, as the UN refers to those refugees who haven’t managed to make it outside their country’s borders.

Pitting the “conservatives” against the “liberals,” this war, which has been simmering literally longer than anyone alive can remember, has its roots in the post-independence opening up of the country, when an enterprising few became overnight land barons, clearing, or seizing massive tracts of land that became the foundation for the sorts of multi-generational fortunes that are the stuff of Gabriel Garcia Marquez’s epics.

This is Silvana Paternostro’s Colombia, from which she became a different kind of refugee, she tells us, when sent as a more or less oblivious teenager to the United States for the prestigious North American liberal arts education marking a right of passage for the children of the world’s elites.

The experience turned her into a liberal, or maybe even worse, and soon, working as a journalist and living in New York, she finds herself sympathizing with Sandinistas and at ease with the EZLN. She draws the line at fraternizing with the FARC, Colombia’s largest left-wing insurgent army, only through a state of almost willful denial until, with a commission from the New York Times Magazine in hand, she at last confronts her tortured relationship with her country of birth and returns to Colombia.



Generically, her people are conservatives, bloodstained landgrabbers, a latifundia family so famous that the guerilla has vowed not to stop until they have kidnapped every last one of the Montblancs. But individually, Paternostro rediscovers, they are beloved, churchgoing grandmothers, great-uncles and cousins, kind, funny, quirky upright citizens living in Barranquilla, people with whom she shared rights of passage who she now finds vacillating between denial and horror at the outrages being perpetrated upon Colombian civil society. Stuck in Barranquilla, getting up late and scandalizing her grandmother with her New York night-owl lifestyle, she is unable even to visit the family farm of her childhood memories. It is unsafe to go anywhere near it, and the family have left its operation in the hands of acceptably proletarian managers.

Visiting that farm becomes the cornerstone, both of the article Paternostro hopes to write for the New York Times Magazine, an article she does eventually write, and of the book. The final visit itself is brief, not much more than a luncheon, really, and secured by the army, but the dramatic conceit of the outing succeeds in holding our attention because of Paternostro’s ability to make us care—about Colombia, yes, but also about her feelings.

The Colombia which emerges is a vast, jungled land only nominally ruled by Bogotá's oblivious and absurdly centralized political elite. This transplanted European city barricaded away somewhere up in the Andes comes across as an entirely different country from the hot, fertile lowlands, where century-old land disputes are contested with the latest military hardware by freelance armies. Both the FARC and its allied acronyms on the "left," and the paramilitary errand-boys of the "right," fund their bloody self-fulfilling military prophecies by taxing, enforcing, securing or otherwise participating in the narcotics business. It is the ancient liberal versus conservative conflict, now fueled by drug money, with the hapless rural population caught in the crossfire.

At the end of her journey, back in New York, Paternostro seems to have found, at least, her own personal emotional closure. She takes down the map on which she had traced the many massacres and battlefields and packs away the photo album of childhood memories, treating the failed state of Colombia like a failed relationship. There are memories good and bad, and one hopes to have learned something, but ultimately, it may be time to move on.